I disagree
Like I said above this really doesn't matter. What matters is that exact scenario last night with Saito on the mound. It doesn't matter that Longoria has done in the past against OTHER pitchers. He was 1 for 2 with a HR against Saito, but he also struck out the other time, that doesn't tell me nearly enough to make a sound judgement about the SS numbers vs. the season long numbers.
That's not a whole lot different than his numbers vs. LHP, Longoria has pretty even splits. But anyway Zobrist has .921 OPS vs. RHP which is indeed higher.
RBIs, really? And I'm not sure where you're looking but he's batting .284/.385/.448/.832 in the second half with a higher BABIP than in the first half (.320 vs. .340). And Longoria? His BABIP in the first half was .324...
ISO: .271 vs. .259, don't mind if I do
4.62 PA/K for Longoria and 5.37 PA/K for Zobrist. I overstated this a bit but still Zobrist has the edge and compared to the PA/BB (9.14 for Longoria vs. 6.37 for Zobrist) I'd say Zobrist's discipline is better pretty easily.