He threw a 1 hit 17 strikeout game against the '99 Champ Yankees. He also beat the Yanks and Clemens with a complete game 2-0 shutout in Yankee stadium in 2000.
I've just seen a few more games than you have. He's throwing a beautiful game, but not one of the most dominating games that I have ever seen. Not yet. Maybe after 9 I'll change my opinion.
None of those teams have .500 Batting Averages. He didn't just give up hits in that last game. Everything was scorched. No bloopers. No bleeders. He is not ready for the bigs. I'd rather have that POS Aaron Small this year.