He hasn't played one game in the majors and he has limited ST experience, so what makes you so sure that he is ready to step into a full time ML job? Franchises like the Red Sox are not big on letting players learn on the job. The scrutiny that a kid would be subject to as he goes through the inevitable growing pains might not be the best way to break him into the majors. I don't see them going "sink or swim" with this kid next year. Hell, they weren't ready to throw Papelbon into the rotation coming out of ST regardless of Foulke's status. You can keep saying it all you want, but repeating it over and over will not make it happen, nor does it mean that it is the right decision, even if the FO does it.