It was a bad deal. Suppan spit the bit big time. I don't know if it was fear of the big stage or what (let's not forget his meltdown on 3B in game 3 of the 2004 WS), but if he hadn't sucked so much in Sept '03 and made the ALCS roster and won game 7 in relief, the trade would have been worth it to me if he never threw another pitch for the Sox. There's nothing wrong with short term success. A world series banner hangs forever. Sometimes young talent has to be sacrificed to get it. Obviously, the FO should try not to trade the next Albert Pujols or the next Pedro, but sometimes the guys you trade turn out to be pretty good, e.g. Freddie Sanchez.