And if you are right, I would either unload Loretta or relegate him to a utility role like he has in Houston. If you are wrong, you'll have to resort to Cora fulltime or you'll have to trade some prospects to get someone. I'd have Loretta. I think I am better positioned. You are exposed if Pedroia underperforms or gets injured. It happens.
We have established major league back ups at 5 positions in case of injury. WMP can handle any of the three OF positions if one of the starters go down. Is he a step down? Yes, but he is a proven MLer with some flaws in his game. At first and third, Hinske can step in. He's not a good player. He's average at best, but he has been a major league starter or platoon player at both postions. Cora is a temporary solution if there is an injury at short or second. If either guy were to go down for a prolonged period, the FO would have to make an acquisition. Lugo is a proven MLer, so the only risk is injury. With Pedroia, there is the risk of nonperformance in addition to the injury risk. We are more vulnerable at 2B than any position other than the bullpen. Just my opinion.