But it is all from my initial post which you have cherry-picked. Haven't we already done this dance? Only a few posts later I gave a more in-depth evaluation that you apparently forgot, which goes to my point that your memory is selective. Congratulations, you have cherry-picked a post to line up with your selective memory. The rest of my posts in that thread and my recollection of my opinion of him at the time mean nothing to you. You will hold onto one post as being my definitive position on the matter even though it still doesn't say what you recollected. As you noted, you made a few extrapolations and assumptions? Well the subsequent posts in the thread proved those assumptions and extrapolations to be wrong.
Your post that started this argument was not a provocative post to generate lively debate. You didn't throw out a provocative player assessment or anything like that. Your post was just a random attack on me that had nothing to do with a discussion of the Red Sox pitching depth as compared to the Yankees and the Rays. The thread was not a discussion of Schilling, nor was it a discussion of the FO. Your post was out of place and it added nothing to the discussion. It didn't provoke a discussion of any baseball issues, but started a flare up of a you said- I said boring discussion. You should be embarrassed that a man of your intelligence stooped to such a level and is fighting so hard to defend his pettiness