People are all caught up in the emotion of the new toy. Teams do not give away the starting jobs of their cleanup hitter based on a couple of good weeks from a guy while the cleanup hitter/All Star is on a 15 day DL. Second, Youk's trade value right now is well below his true worth. Cherrington has no balls to pull a trade where he essentially gives away an All Star and eats his contract. He hasn't made a single bold move yet. I don't see him starting off with Youk, unless Youk is having fist fights in the club house. 3. When Youk comes back, the Sox will do one of the following with WMB: Option him to AAA, Put him on the bench, or try him in the OF where we have openings. He will not start at 3B before Youk gets the opportunity to prove that he can still play or he punches someone in the face.
As for Nava, he is not a major league player. He lacks size and skill. He's hot right now, and they brought him up at the right time, but he will fade. I have said it before. He is comparable to Morgan Burkhart but with a lot less power. His career will follow a similar path. He'll never see the majors after this season. The fact that he is here is not cause for excitement. It is cause for concern, because it is an indication of the severe deficiencies in our OF. BTW: All those years ago I got all excited about Morgan Burkhart. I have learned not to get excited about career bush leaguers.