The discussion isn't about what you want, it's what Theo wanted, since we're arguing the merits of Theo's abilities compared to Cashman's. And the Yankees are paying him about $16 million a season, since the Rangers gave about $65 million in the trade.
http://www.recordonline.com/archive/2003/11/30/dbcol30w.htm
The team that Schilling didn't want to goto was the Red Sox. Theo had that dinner with him to convince him to accept the trade.
Again, it was only a wow deal because of other factors, namely the hardheadedness of the DBacks front office. Theo's "skills" had nothing to do with convincing the DBacks to take the inferior offer.
Robinson Cano is a candidate for the ROY, plus he looked really good in the postseason. And let's wait for a couple of years before annointing Lester and Papelbon as the next Schiiling and Pedro. For a Red Sox fan, you sure aren't very aware of your own team's recent history and lack of dependence on its farm system. Our two teams have always had similar philosophies, it just happens that our owner spends more money than yours.