Wow, you name a guy who was hurt last year, and this year. Let's see who made more erros. Mags had 30 Errors in his 6 full seasons in the bigs. In Manny's last 6 seasons he's made 24. Oh look at that ... interesting stat isn't it? OK, maybe you got me at the plate. Lets see in the last 6 seasons Manny has averaged 37.5 HRs and 117 RBIs, while Mags has averaged 29 HRs 109 RBIs. Nope don't got me there either. Mags is only 2 years younger, and if I'm not mistaken he's got a pretty big contract as well, so I don't really see that being much of an upgrade. Maybe you should try again, and this time maybe don't suggest that we get someone who has been hurt for an entire season.
BTW if you're 30 then I'm Manny Ramirez.