Those 3 games were against the 25th, 26th, and 28th best passing defenses in the league. #25 being, of course, the worst defense I've had the displeasure of watching on a week to week basis -- and who just got torched by Jamarcus freakin' Russell.
He's gotten better, no doubt about it. But he needs to do it against a team that's proven they can stop the pass before I'll be sold that he's anything more than a capable back-up QB in this league.
And QB Rating is a deceiving stat. We're not going to find a common ground here -- you consider a game in which a QB racks up completion % and yardage because his WR's can run with a ball a good game, I consider it something that any QB in the NFL could do if that's what was asked of them. It's great for moving the ball down field, it's not great for putting up points and getting the ball into the endzone, which is the point of offense. The Patriots are in a situation where there combination of talent, and the schedule they've played (which is plain awful) allows
Please, quit acting like the Patriots running game is non-existant when it's in the top 1/3 of the league in yardage and average. He was managing the game against the Broncos... I'd be shocked if he threw more than 3 balls 10+ yards.
He's not playing at Tom Brady's level, he's not playing at the Manning brothers' level, he's been about average, what you would expect from somebody throwing to the guy's he's throwing to.