To be fair it was really only Burnett who requested him, but everyone liked throwing to him. I have no problem with Molina as a defensive catcher, he's one of the absolute best in the game even though he's a backup. And he may arguably be the best throwing catcher in the game. You can't get much better than Molina behind the dish, but the dude just absolutely cannot hit. AT ALL. Not that we need a hitter for our backup catcher, because with our lineup we don't. Nor would I have minded Molina coming back. But with Cervelli's emergence the Yanks were clear that they were going to cut Molina loos and go with Franky. While he's a defensive downgrade, he's definitely a better hitter. But to be fair, every Yankee who worked with Cervelli last year during his first stint when Posada and Molina were both hurt at one point praised Cervelli for his game-calling ability. Especially Sabathia. Those two worked very well together and Cervelli caught like 4 of his starts in a row, even after Posada came back. So defensively, I have no concerns with Cervelli. He's not as good a thrower, or an overall defender as Molina, but he's a good game-caller. Even Piazza had very high praise for him when he was playing for Italy in the WBC. Now I know that doesn't mean much coming from Piazza, a very one-dimensional catcher, but it seems everywhere Cervelli goes people rave about him.