I know it's a good trade, believe me, I'm just disappointed about them trading my favorite player, which I know is getting the the way of my objectivity a little bit. I'm glad they solidified the rotation, just disappointed it was at Melky's expense. Even before he came up Melky was my favorite player in the Yanks system. I saw him play his first big league game in '05, and was at the game in '06 when he got called up and played right field in that Johnson vs Beckett game where the RJ got ROCKED and we lost like 13-4 or something. Even as he made an error that night, I still argued and defended him the whole time. The clutch hitting and energy he brought to our club this past year was special and it's unfortunate that he's gone now. I must say though, I'm really happy we won it all with that group while they were still together. Matsui, Melky, Damon, the core 4, A-Rod, etc. Only thing that could have made it better was Mussina and Giambi being there. But players come and go in this game, and it's a part of the game we as fans have to accept. Hopefully this move makes us a better team and gives Melky the opportunity to progress as a player, and maybe one day we'll see him back in the Bronx. I'm sure he's devastated about being dealt, and I'm sure Robbie Cano's not too thrilled either. Not that it should, but hopefully his best friend being dealt doesn't impact his performance at all.
As for Crawford and Holliday. The difference is that Crawford fits better with this team as a top of the order bat and strong defender. Holliday is a one-dimensional player who is probably in his prime. I don't see him improving much beyond what he's already done. Not to mention he's a righty, and I don't like his swing for this park. Crawford on the other hand would be a legitimate power threat while stealing about 50 bases a year.
What are you talking about? The only thing Gardner can do better than Melky is run. Melky plays a solid defense, has an above-average arm, and is Babe Ruth compared to Gardner. It's not even close.