Manny is the best hitter in the MLB. f*** man, he had a torn meniscus. Do you understand that kind of injury? I've had the same damn thing as him. YOU CAN'T BEND YOUR LEG. If that torn piece of his meniscus got lodged into his knee joint, it locks. I don't know the extent of it, but it's similar to Tek's injury that required surgery. They don't always need surgery because the extent of such injuries don't always require surgery, but you can NOT expect someone to f***ing "tough it out." They're still human beings.
Pedroia played just over ONE month of baseball in the bigs. It's amazing how quickly people will write a kid like Pedroia off.
I'm also amazed that you're content with Wily Mo, but Pedroia needs to go. What's your reasoning there? Wily Mo has "proved" himself? WMP has shown very promising signs, but he has in NO way sold me that he'll be a legitimate OFer. I believe he can be, I just need to see it. If you're willing to give WMP a starting job, then how the HELL how are you not willing to give Pedroia a chance?