Considering the Sox' defensive woes, I'm shocked you all left Reese out of the lineup. Noony got it pretty decent, because I love Daubach. Here's my take:
1) Damon CF
2) Youkilis/Mueller 3B
3) Ortiz DH
4) Ramirez LF
5) Nixon RF
6) Garciapara SS
7) Varitek C
8) Reese 2B
9) Daubach 1B
Tony LaRussa (a pretty good manager) once made a comment about alternating lefty/righty hitters in the lineup so it's harder for the other manager to make the decision to put in a "specialist."
I still remember when Atlanta was a powerhouse, and got dominated by otherwise worthless lefty's (Grahme Lloyd) because Chipper Jones/Fred McGriff/Ryan Klesko hit back to back to back in the middle of the order. (Yes, Chipper's a switch hitter, but was dreadful while hitting right handed at the time).
Thus, my reasoning for the alternation.
Other comments:
I think Garciaparra's got to break out of his slump. He simply isn't this bad a player.
Ortiz is a VERY dangerous hitter. He should be really dangerous with Manny behind him. (Note. This MAY cause Ramirez to be walked more, but when Nixon's on, he is also very dangerous).
I gotta have Reese in there because of his defense.
I have Youk hitting #2 because of his history for OBP.
Call up Daubach, send Millar to AAA (if he refuses assignment, let him go)