Actually, I take it back. Pudge still appears to have something left in his arm. He's gunned down 31% of basestealers this year. That's worth a lot more than Gonzalez's, Woodward's, or Anderson's defense.
Ryan Kalish is scalding the ball this month. In 54 AB's in August he has a .333/.419/.685/1.105 line.
Lars Anderson has a .346 OPS since the all-star break, which has spanned 74 AB's. The cold spell has brought his OPS under .700 for the year.
I see that you are trying to be somewhat positive about Alex Gonzalez. I don't understand why he inspires even that much confidence in someone. He may be a good defender, but his glove won't come anywhere close to offsetting the horrendous offensive output the Red Sox are going to be seeing from his bat.
Nick Green was doing the same thing, and there's a chance that Gonzalez will make it look even worse.