I think they're hypocritical. Since rankings are updated each week, shouldn't they reflect what's actually happening on the field (and not in their studios)? It's obviously all based on opinion, but begs the question: can a team be considered good only because of its roster, while another is unfairly dismissed for doing good things in games right now? The overrateds and underrateds...
If they didn't include won-loss records, the AL East would look like a powerhouse. But we know every AL East team has many flaws... however, Toronto's big IFs aren't pitchers coming off TJ, like NY and Boston. Pearson has a pulled groin, '20 OPS leader Hernandez has Covid, and Springer hasn't even played a game yet.