The Rice is wrong! The best starting pitchers were absolutely as good/better, but after that forget it. Relievers were not better then, and the backend starters were Al Nipper-esque...batting practice guys that hitters feasted on. I am from that era too. Yes, Big Papi did go out on top, just right before the specialized pitching reached new heights in velocity, spin. I think the best hitters, the best average/power guys simply are really great athletes too and certainly compare favorably or better than the best of all-time...