Not sure I agree at 1B. I think people forget how good Napoli was that year. Hanram has a higher BA, but Napoli's OPS was 45 points higher than Hanley's is right now and the other night not withstanding, 2013 Napoli is the better defensive player. Napoli also is/was the better baserunner (I'm not talking about speed, but he was a smart baserunner and never had the brain farts out there that Hanley seems to have all too often). I call it a wash at best, and IMO a slight edge to Naps.
Pedroia 2013 and 2016 are also a wash pretty much a was, but I'll go with the 2013 version if only defensively, because 28 yo Pedey had slightly better range than his 31 yo counterpart.
Catcher is a really tough call. Leon >> Salty on defense, but offensively, Salty struck out a ton; he also had 40 doubles that year. Leon isn't going to keep this up (nobody ever has in the history of the game) and when he crashes back to Earth it isn't going to be pretty.
The 2013 team was a veteran team that seemingly was better than the sum of its parts. This year's team has more raw talent, but the operative word there is raw.