I told you my points:
The Sox have just a handful of players 25 or younger, and they are not the problem, as a whole.
26 and 27 is near or part of prime. Rafaela, Abreu and other 25-27 year olds should be on the upswing.
We have capable back-ups for Anthony (3 OF'ers and Yoshida) Mayer (IKF) Durbin (Monasterio) and Early (Sandoval, Tolle and maybe Oviedo & Crawford).
I'm not sure what your two false choices offered is all about.
Most of us saw the major mistake we made, this winter. Most of us argued we had a surplus in OF/DHs and a shortage in capable IF'ers. Most of us saw our pen was thin.
I don't think our youth is the issue. In fact, I think the opposite: the youth is the only thing we can be optimistic about and not just for 2017 and beyond, but this year. Now, arguing that we shouldn't need Early and Anthony to carry us has a lot of merit, but most good teams are looking at a couple under 26 guys as major factors. The difference is, they better "other players."
I'm not pretending all my suggestions were better than we made, as guys like Suarez and Polanco are doing poorly, but many are doing well. Almost all are doing better than Durbin & IKF. (Note: I liked the idea of adding one of these two as a complimentary piece, but along with someone like Paredes, KMarte, Neto, Hoerner or even BLowe/Donovan types.)
My point about PIT was about you bringing them up. (My guess is they miss the playoffs, again.)