I really think we have to set things up for 2025 with Rafaela viewed as the FT CF'er, and this is not just about last night's catch. The guy is flat out awesome in CF, and below average at SS on D. I'm okay with going into 2025 with rafaela as the 4th or 5th string SS (or even 2Bman,) but that should be an emergency situation worse than even 2024 was.
Beginning with Rafaela in CF, that forces Duran to be the FT LF'er, because his arm is not a Fenway RF arm. That's 2 slots in the OF filled for 2025, right now- in my book.
Assuming no O'Neill or O'Neill replacement, that leaves RF and DH to find enough PAs for these guys:
L Yoshida (should only DH or platoon DH or be traded)
L Abreu (kills RHPs and could use more consistent D in RF)
R Refsnyder (should really DH or play Fenway LF or Yankee Stadium RF.)
L Anthony (may start 2025 in AAA and "solve the problem" by staying there, but eventually a squeeze will happen.
If Refsnyder bolts after 2025, we'll have a very solid OF, but all will be lefties. That may not be a major problem, if they all keep doing so well. but Abreu need to prove he can hit LHPs. Maybe Campbell can play LF by the start 2026, but then how do we play everyone without moving Duran to CF and Rafaela to RF and then what about Anthony.
I'll say it again: we are loaded and will be overloaded in the OF. We have serious needs building up our staff and an owner that seems reluctant on spending on top pitchers- large and long. We should trade an LHB OF'er, not named Duran, this winter.