Maybe, if they were asking with the idea that they will play him there, no matter what he answers,
I see your point, but it does seem like the best way to approach the situation, after what happened with the DH move. It is likely better than them coming up to him, one day, and saying, here is a 1Bman's mitt: we want you to go out and show us what you can do in practice at 1B.
You think that sits better with him (and the team?)