Do we really expect all GM acquisitions and holdovers to have plus WARs every year?
That's the mark?
The W-L record is really all that matters?
Recent results are all that matters?
To those who answer yes to the last two, what's to say about 9-2 in the last 11?
Brez sucks because his utility depth has negative WARs? LMAO. Because he played the $140M guy who hit well, last year and the $90M guy who has like the 3rd or 4th best OPS on the tea over the last 3 years? He was supposed to trade them? LMAO. For what?
Because he kept Duran, when 75% of this board was screaming how stupid it would be to trade our "best" or "top 3 offensive weapon, when our weakness is offense?" Again, LMAO!
No doubt, Brez has made mistakes, and some like missing out on Brez ended up working out well. Some mistakes looked reasonable at the time, but backfired. Such is the fate or every GM to varying degrees.
You ask a GM to make moves and additions that improve the roster. You judge them, when they happen and again in hindsight. Such is the fate of all GMs.
IMO, Brez fixed the decades long problem with the team- the pitching pipeline to the farm. Much is still TBD, but IMO, it's improved vastly. He's also added an ungodly amount of quality SP'ers to the 26, that I'm not sure any Sox GM has ever done, and he's only been the GM for 3 winters and 2 deadlines. Crochet, Suarez, Gray, Bennett & Tolle. What do we hear, instead? "OMG- HE TRADED HARRISON!!!" This was the same guy the same people bitched about him trading Devers for. The comedy never ends, here.
Yes, he botched a major are of need, last winter- the big bat. The pen was also neglected, but hey- newsflash- The budget is not unlimited, and he's traded more prospects than DD. You wanted more than what was possible. Okay, no Suarez or Gray and yes another bat. That would have changed everything?
Sorry for the ramble, the hyperbole & the insinuations that may come across as personal or finger pointing away from myself. I share in much of what I just ranted about and against. I suggested many winter moves that turned out worse than what Brez ended up doing. I'm no better than anyone here: I just felt the need to vent.
We are finally winning and looking like the team some or many of us thought we might be, this year, but damn, Monasterio has a negative WAR. The world is ending!