I don't really disagree with anything, here, either.
Ideally, we should try to avoid maga deals, especially long term ones, and even the one for Bregman might have been avoidable, had we put our faith in Meidroth and found another prospect to include in the Crochet deal.
I'm not for trading higher prospects for short term gains. The Aldo Ramirez for Schwarber deal is about the highest we've gone since Beeks for Nate in 2018- both seemed to work well.
IMO, we need a solid #2 SP'er. I doubt Dobbins, Houck, Crawford or anyone else in the system can step into that roile, shortly or even in a year or two. Houck and Sandoval probably have the best chance, unless Buehler comes around. I do not want us trading a top 8 or so prospect for a rental, but I would like to see a longer term addition that fills that role, and would be willing to pay for it in money and or higher level prospects.