I was joking around. I also like the idea of signing JD.
I'm not sure what it would take to trade for Stanton, so it's hard to compare which plan is best.
Apparently, HRam will be cleared to play 1B next year. Signing JD or trading for Stanton allows them to DH FT, if needed, and to also fill the 4th OF'er opening.
MLBTR...
Clark Spencer of the Miami Herald reported Saturday that Boston is “definitely in play” for Stanton, but sources tell Jon Heyman of FanRag that the Red Sox don’t look like the front-runners for him at the moment. Rather, the Sox are more focused on other players, including free agent outfielder J.D. Martinez, per Heyman.
It will be hard for DD to know for sure what others are offering, and Jeter & Co. may master creating a bidding war that is nonexistent, but I really do not think the return will be as great as you project, even without taking on Prado's sunken cost.
Plus, Prado probably can't even play 2B next year.
Assuming JD Martinez signs for $150M/6, look at this comp (luxury tax dollars):
Stanton
Age 28 $25M
Age 29 $25M
Age 30 $25M
Age 31 $25M JD $25M
Age 32 $25M JD $25M
Age 33 $25M JD $25M
Age 34 $25M JD $25M
Age 35 $25M JD $25M
Age 36 $25M JD $25M
Age 37 $25M
(Note: JD starts next season at age 30 and turns 31 in August. Stanton does not turn 29 until next November.)
I'll take the extra year at age 37 in exchange for the 3 years at ages 28-30.
We could trade for Stanton AND keep JBJ.
Word is HRam can play 1B next year.
Stanton can DH and be the 4th OF'er, when needed (12-20 games with no OF injuries). HRam can DH those 12-20 games, thereby giving him some rest. Use Travis or Swihart at 1B when HRam DHs or sign someone like Duda for a 1 year cheap deal.
,
Year one, yes, once you reset, but the tax on Stanton's $25M luxury cost will be less over the length of the deal.
My point was that if the Yanks can get Stanton and reset, I think they'll kick the tires.
A little bit deceiving. He was at 2.8 year 4, so the 4.0 average WAR for the first 4 years was front-loaded.
3 out of 8 years with a WAR over 2.9 is probably not what the Yankee FO hoped for. (He had 4 straight years over 3.5 before signing with the Yanks and only 2 out of 8 seasons over 3.4 with the Yanks.)
I wouldn't call the signing a bust, but I am glad the Sox didn't win that bidding war.
Committing to 5 years for 1Bman of Hosmer's quality is asking for worse than HRam & Pablo.
1B should be a position of greater power and offense than Hosmer brings to the table.