Yea, based on defense only- and that's the point I was making about JBJ vs Beni in AA.
The only reason Beni can now be viewed as "more ML ready" offensively than Moncada was is by looking at hindsight data.
True, Moncada's K rate was obscene, even in the minors, but I seriously doubt you'll find any scout that felt Beni was more ML ready offensively than Moncada before their call-ups. Beni was more ML ready because of bhis defense, and he was called up because of the black hole we had in LF and us getting stiffed on the planned Carlos Beltran trade.