At the start of the season many felt losing Papi and not replacing him with a big hitter was a huge mistake. They did not think that acquisition of Sale, Thornburg and Moreland would be enough. We only have a .750 team OPS as we near the halfway point. Those of us who felt we would still be a top 3 or 5 run-scoring team appear to have overestimated our projections on offense.
There is another area that was of great concern to some at the start of the season: un unbalanced offense with 2-3 "black holes" in the line-up. On this point, I will say that as of now, we only have just one black hole, and it's a big one: 3B.
We are actually one of just a very few contending teams that only has two position with an OPS below .708. One is a surprising 2B! After JBJ's slow start, some felt CF would be a black hole. Now, CF is our highest OPS position on the team! Many felt that since Leon's 2016 season was a fluke, our 2017 catcher OPS would be worse. I argued that losing Hanigan and Holaday's putrid offense would balance out the projected decline in Leon's offense. I also projected a better year for Vaz. While catchers have our third worst OPS, the OPS is significantly better than 2016. Here are our positional OPS:
.558 3B (Totally unacceptable)
.666 2B (This is a big surprise. Pedey is at .720 though.)
.708 C (When compared to other teams, this is good.)
.732 LF
.753 DH (One expects better from this position.)
.807 RF (I expected near .900 here.)
.827 1B (Mostly coming from Moreland.)
.838 SS (Bogey has pulled his weight and then some on expectations.)
.879 CF (I'll say it again--MOVE JBJ UP IN THE LINE-UP! He's now got our best OPS.)
How about balance by batting slot? We only have 1 slot below .725 and that is the 9 slot at .553- a black hole if ever there was one. What's shocking to me is that our second worst slot has been the 5 slot. Again, moving JBJ might solve this.
(Top PA players listed)
.553 9th slot (Marrero 94, Marco 48, Vaz 45, Leon 42)
.725 5th (Moreland 118, HRam 83, Beni 44, Young 33)
.730 7th (JBJ 110, Rutledge 54, Pablo 48, Young 30, Leon 30, Vaz 24)
.742 6th (JBJ 69, Moreland 64, Bogey 40, Young 40, HRam 31, Pedey 20)
.760 8th (Leon 74, Vaz 67, Pablo 46, JBJ 35, Rut 31, Young 22)
.779 1st (Betts 218, Pedey 78, Bogey 39)
.791 4th (HRam 141, Moreland 101, Beni 80)
.810 2nd (Pedey 158, Beni 156)
.830 3rd (Bogey 212, Betts 111)
Some other offense observations. We have a .750 OPS as a team, and...
.727 the last 28 days
.709 the last 14 days
.745 vs RHP (but .754 when a righty starts)
.775 vs LHP (but surprisingly .734 when a lefty starts)
Not surprising: .764 at home and .738 away, although the gap is lower than recent years.
By age group:
.803 25 and under (This is encouraging)
.676 26-30 (This from the prime years of a career?)
.763 31+
.794 RISP (Something many have been crying about in recent years, buy is now better than our overall OPS!) It's .798 with RISP and 2 outs.
.717 Late & Close (disappointing)
.752 High Leverage
.429 vs NYY
.592 vs HOU
.650 vs TOR
.651 vs SEA
.673 vs STL
1.102 vs MN
.896 vs TEX
.877 vs MIL
.870 vs PHI
.869 vs CWS
.838 Cubs
(The rest are between .693 and .803)
.780 Day
.736 Night
If you subscribe to the philosophy (as I do) that one of the best ways to improve a team is by upgrading the weakest link, then one big fix is needed:
FIX the 3B Problem!