He does not have much more HR power than Moreland and his glove is over-rated.
He will be costly and want several years. I'm not for putting a lot of money and years into a power position like 1B, on a team sorely lacking power, with someone like Hosmer.
I'd rather go one year again with the best we can get for that length (Morrison? Duda? Alonso?) and then sign DH to squeeze HRam out of his vesting option..
Yes, and as well as many have done, particularly in the pen, only Sale and Kimbrel instill high confidence, but I guess one could say guys like Peacock, Morton, Bauer, Tomlin, Montgomery and even CC Sab have question marks next to their names, too.
I think our biggest need next year is a top clean-up hitter. The best FA I see for that role might be JD Martinez, who would essentially be a DH only. I share your concerns about that, but I don't think any 1B FAs fill the clean-up hitter role adequately.
I think our bench will be fine next year, even if we non tender Holt:
Leon
(Holt)
Travis
Hernandez
Lin
Marrero
Swihart
If sign Nunez, it will be near top notch.
I think you misread my post.
I said he would be MLB's best 4/5 starter, so that implies there is no "list" of better.
My point was, he's pitched like a number 2 all season (and the first half of 2016), but with the low IP totals, he'd have been great as our 4th starter had Porcello and Price pitched like 2016 or before.
Plus, haven't we all done dumb things at some point in our lives (not that what Sale did was dumb), and yet we all know what fine and upstanding people we are!
I thought linking all Japanese players to Dice-K's flop was tremendously weak. There have been plenty of Japanese success stories.
We've had so many international signing successes, I don't know where to begin. Most have been from Latin America, especially the really good ones. We've also had some pretty good success with Asian player signings. I'm not sure we win in 2013 without Uehara. True, he was proven already, unlike fresh signings, but he and many others prove the gamble is not an impossible gamble.
Remember, we signed Okajima the same year as Dice-K. He was a good signing- very good. The Tazawa signing a couple years later worked out well, too.
Our Top Latin American Signings (many more were failures):
HRam (brought us Beckett & Lowell)
Doubront
Bogaerts
F Montas
Margot (helped get Kimbrel)
Moncada (helped get Sale)
Castillo
Devers
Those kind of ABs are highly frustrating to watch, especially when we desperately need men on base.
Here's my projection: if JBj gets up again, he hits a walk-off.
Some of the excessive unearned runs is probably just bad luck (or timing), and I'm sure our defense has saved many an earned run, so I'm not complaining.
Hopefully, Devers and Bogey can step up their defensive games next year and we can maybe be the top defensive team in MLB.
Not that Davis is doing any better, but he's a better defender (though we don't need a defensive OF replacement) and pinch runner- something we might actually need.