I'm not so sure it's all that easy to say, "Just sign Gio," but of course one could say the same to me when I say, "Just trade for Ryan." One choice does not involve trading away a key player, so that looks better, on paper, but in reality, is JH really going to rework Bregman's deal, give Chapman a raise to stay here, pay all the new extensions and also pay Gio? I sure hope so, but even if he does, I still think we need Ryan, too.
I wrote about the long list of SP'er depth we had over the winter. Look what happened. We ended up with Newcomb in the rotation to start the season! Our "ace" from 2024 floundered then went on the IL and will miss 2026, too. Crawford missed the whole season, and our $21M solution pitcher was just demoted to the pen. Criswell filled in nicely, last year- on the IL now. Dobbins was kind of an unknown and might have been slotted 11th or 12th, and he went out for the season.
Now, we are supposed to count on the same names, but less of them with Buehler, Houck, and newcomb all gone to help us just stay even with this year? No disrespect, here, but count me out.
1. I think penciling in Tolle as a top 4 SP'er is a big risk, despite me thinking he may be as good as Ryan real soon. He may also have his inning restricted in 2026.
2. Gio is not on the list until we sign him, so it's Crochet, Bello and maybe Tolle for 150 IP.
3. Your list of Sandoval, Dobbins, Crawford, Fitts, Harrison, Early & Perales should be our 5-7 starters not 4-7.
4. I see it like this:
Option A (We bring Gio back): Crochet, Ryan, Bello, Gio and Tolle, Sandoval, Dobbins, Crawford, Fitts, Harrison, Early & Perales as 5-7.
Option B (No Gio): Crochet, Ryan, Bello, Keller and Tolle, Sandoval, Dobbins, Crawford, Fitts, Harrison, Early & Perales as 5-7.
We need to look at improving our rotation- not keeping it about the same and hoping we have less injuries.