Well, there has to be a better choice to be a bad call. Maybe there was a pitcher who dominated more than JBJ's 9 RBIs, almost all of which put us a head near the end of 3 games.
9 RBIs was a third of all the runs we scored.
Price pitched 2 games in the ALCS not 3 and had a decent, but not great 3.38 ERA-- 32 outs out of 44 batters faced.
E-O pitched in 2 games (7.1 IP) with a 2.45 ERA-- 22 outs out of 31 batters faced.
Again, I don't see a pitcher as deserving as Price was in the WS.
Recap:
JBJ clears the bases loaded with a dbl to put us up 5-4 in game 2. (We were down 1 game to none.)
Down 5-4 in game 4, JBJ hit a 2 run job to put us up 1
Game 5, tie game, he hits a 3 run job to clinch the win.
I never said it was all about PAs vs batters faced. I said that was the deciding factor (assuming everything else was kind of even).