And yet regression isn’t on your mind at all? Betts is going to continue this unrepeatable pace?
Many times I have said we will have injuries and we will see some players fall short of expectations and decline, possibly even players not yet at prime years. Of course it is possible and probable that more than 1 or 2 players will do worse than 2018. We saw in 2017 how more declined than improved despite their age curve suggested growth. However, the same could happen to every team, even the great Yankees.
Is King Kong JD going to surpass 1.000 OPS again?
Good chance he does- good chance he doesn't. I'd say the odds are close to 50-50 that either Betts or JD repeat or better 2018 while the other one does not.
Can Xander keep up his career season?
Why not? He's only 26. I could see him hit .900 or even .950, but of course, he could fall back to .800 or lower. Some of his lower numbers from the past involved him playing through wrist injuries.
Yes, you’ve got some parts that either were hurt or underachieved, but the core of your offense stayed healthy and played bonkers. Expecting that plus improvements in health and production could happen, but it’s far more likely that someone crucial slips back a little or spends some time on the DL.
Betts & Bogey spent time on the DL. Pedey missed the whole year. Devers missed a lot of time. Nunez played hobbled. Vaz missed time. Sale & ERod missed time and were not the same by the playoffs. There's a ton of room for more production by these guys just playing more, even if their numbers dip slightly.
Look, I get the argument that some or many can dip, but we are talking about what is expected, and you seem to expect the worst from just about every Sox player and the best from every Yankee player.
I'm expecting growth from many Yankee players as the near prime, but I could easily ask if Judge will ever repeat his career best. (I actually expect Judge to have his best season in 2019.)
I don’t think the Sox win 100 this year. I doubt the yanks win 100. It’s very difficult to be in a division with two other very strong clubs and win as much as our teams did last year. The reasoning was that Tampa sucked and then went on a late run that was crazy to get them to 90 wins. They’re going to be good again and probably from the outset. Yes, we’ve got the worst team in baseball in our division and a middling squad likely hellbent on rebuilding, so that’ll help rack up wins. But games vs BOS, NYY and TB are going to be dogfights and that’s 38 games of the schedule. Last year TB was a pushover til June and the Sox owned them early. This year, they’ll be good. Let’s just assume that those 38 games are splits. 19-19. In order to win 100, a squad would have to go 81-43 (65%) against the rest and that’ll be hard to do again.
Cleveland is worse, and many AL teams did not improve on paper. I'm expecting 100+ wins from both the Yanks and Sox. I've been rong before, but these two teams are light years better than others in the AL (except Houston, but even they did not improve on paper).