Those were the easy choices. It's gets a bit harder when the next guys are ready....
Pedroia (Go to 12 pitchers: Weber or Brewer to AAA or DFA/trade Thornburg)
Holt (Must decide who to keep- Nunez, Holt or Pearce)
Johnson (Weber or Brewer to AAA or DFA/trade Thornburg)
Eovaldi (Weber or Brewer to AAA or DFA/trade Thornburg)
Final 100% healthy 25 man roster:
SP (6): Sale, Price, Porcello, Eovaldi, ERod, Johnson
RP (6): Barnes, Workman, Brazier, Walden, Hembree, Velazquez
C (2): Vaz & Leon
1B (1): Moreland
2B (1): Chavis
3B (1): Devers
SS (1): Bogaerts
LF (1): Benintendi
CF (1): JBJ
RF (1): Betts
DH/OF (1): JD
Bench (3): Holt and 2 from: Nunez, Pedey or Pearce.
A look at the final 3 slots:
Holt: He can play 1B, as can Chavis, and he can play a decent OF, so I slot him ahead of Pearce & Nunez.
Nunez: He needs to start hitting, or he may be the odd man out, but he's more reliable than Pedey (which isn't saying much). He can also play a better OF than Pearce, when healthy.
Pedey: He will not be DFA'd. He may retire, if it comes down to him not being able to play more than 2 times a week. I think he stays over Pearce, if he can show he can play 3+ times a week, if needed.
Pearce: If he doesn't start hitting, I think he'll be the odd man out. Even if he does hit, we may keep Holt, Nunez & Pedey over him.
Tough call.
(DFA/Traded: Thornburg)