I know longevity matters, and that's why I added the qualifier about who determines the deciding factors.
Fisk was here for a over 4,000 PAs, but if someone wants to put Pedey ahead of him, because he has 50% more games with the Sox, I'm fine with that.
If longevity (with the Sox) is a major factor, then Pedro, Fisk, Lynn, Nomar, Tiant and others get knocked down significantly, which is okay.
One could start another thread on who was the best Sox player for a 5-7 year span. That list may look something like this:
1T Williams & Pedro
3 Clemens
4 Young
5 ???