I may end up wrong, for sure, and I have never doubted the value of Cole, so you don't have to act like I have.
Houck is no longer our #6: Whitlock is.
Richards is looking as good as Kluber, but the sample size is small for both. "Never been bad?" The guy was a top 20 pitcher way back, when healthy.
Really? 5 IP by Garcia in the minors is worth anything? Please, jacko. You know better.
Certainly, there is a significant chance Pivetta and Perez "crash and burn" or Eovaldi gets hurt or stumbles, but you seriously neglect the chances your 2-5 starters do, too, or at least your 3-5's.
Yes, Montgomery has put up a 2+WAR season, before, but so has Pivetta. Somehow you only twist the good for Yankee pitchers and the bad for Sox pitchers.
ERod is NOT pitching to his norm. His norm is better than this.
His WHIP is the highest, ever, and by quite a bit.
K rate lowest since '16
So, Sevarino is "ahead" of Sale. Too bad he's not as good.
It is entirely possible Eovaldi puts up a full season of good pitching.
It's entirely possible Pivetta finally does what many felt he could do all along.
It's entirely possible Perez has a decent year.
It's entirely possible Richards does as well as Kluber.
It's entirely possible ERod gets even better at age 28.
It's entirely possible Whitlock bites you guys in the ass.
It's entirely possible Sale is the great addition we need this summer.
The thing is, we may only need 3-4 of these 7 possibilities to happen, maybe less if many of your what ifs don't work out.
Like I said, I still think the Yanks are the faves. You have a better pen and a better ace. The rest is clearly up for debate.