WAR does not penalize or glorify flashy D, but it does reward good to great defenders and penalize poor defenders. (It can actually partially negate a negative WAR, who has a horrific offensive WAR component player. LOL!)
The fact is, Bogey's WAR would be a lot better, if his defense was top notch.
Iggy's WAR would be a lot lower, if he was a bad defender.
Alex Gonzo's offense was actually pretty good- for a SS in those days, but not when he was on the Sox. His offense sucked.