Well, you were sitting right next to the driver on the front seat.
I've always liked Arroyo, except for the injuries, and I don't think we can or should count on him for even 130 games at 2B, next year. I'm also high on Enmanuel Valdez who has like 55 Hrs over the past 2 years and an OPS over .940, this year at AA/AAA, but his defense is suspect, and I would not want to see us go with that combo, all year.
Now, if it comes down to us only having enough funds for another pitcher or 2B/SS, I'm on the side of pitching, but I still see 2B/SS as a high need area. Losing Bogey and not adding anyone will need a lot of "making up" to do elsewhere to just balance that out.