moonslav59
-
Posts
108,902 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
162
Content Type
Profiles
Boston Red Sox Videos
2026 Boston Red Sox Top Prospect Rankings
Boston Red Sox Trade & Free Agent Rumors
Boston Red Sox Fan Guides & Resources
2025 Boston Red Sox Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
Boston Red Sox News, Rumors & Analysis
2026 Boston Red Sox Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
Forums
Blogs
Events
Store
Downloads
Gallery
Everything posted by moonslav59
-
I'm just commenting on your not calling them suspects, instead of prospects. I understand why you believe what you do. Those two have "shown something," so they are no longer total suspects. Either or both could still fall flat, as might Bogey, Renfroe, Beni, and others, going forward. Just about every baseball player is "suspect" to some degree.
-
Certainly, we know enough about some of the prospects received to know brown when we see it. Wink is still a bit unknown, but does not have the same promise he had 2 years ago. The other 3 from that trade have done nothing to distinguish themselves in 2 years. Luis de la Rosa might be one that moves up. The Hamilton and Binelas for Renfroe still are largely unknown, but again, neither have done much to impress, except Hamilton did something to get protected on Rule 5. The Vaz return is way to early to even begin to grade out. Plus, we lost 2 months of Vaz, unlike Beni & Renfroe. Maybe the best Bloom trade has been Hembree & Workman for Pivetta & Seabold. Maybe The McGuire deal will jump to number 1. Mondesi may surprise. I have hopes Valdez and Abrue will convince many it was a good trade. If you combine the Diekman and Vaz trades, it looks real sweet, to me. 3 years of McGuire for 2 months of Vaz and a dump of salary on Diekman, plus 2 pretty good prospects in Valdez & Abreu.
-
Bello is not a prospect, anymore. Casas won't be soon. Do you consider Mayer, Mata and Rafaela "suspects?"
-
Here is my ranking for the bottom of our 40 Man Roster (not to be confused with who will be DFA'd next) 1. Ort 2. Brasier 3. Hamilton 4. Chang 5. Bleier 6. Murphy 7. Mills 8. Dalbec 9. Winckowski 10. Paxton The DFA list would consider positional needs and years of team control and not just skills and value. As reference, here is a rough list of the bottom players in recent years on opening day: 2022: RHern, R Garza, Bazardo, Duran, Downs, DHern, Seabold, Arauz, TShaw, Valdez 2021: J Rosario, H Potts, Brewer, Arauz, M Wilson, Chavis, E Bazardo, Seabold, Brice, Valdez 2020: KHart, Chatham, Shawaryn, Mazza, T-Z Lin, Lucroy, Araus, Chavis, Valdez, Covey, Brewer, Brice, MHall, Walden, Peraza 2019: Reyes, Shepherd, DHern, Lin, Chavis, Lakins, poyner, Walden, STravis, Brewer
-
I think he was referring to T-Ball, but he seems to think all prospects are suspects.
-
I think some of that stuff is overblown. I do think many of these guys would be better served going through a natural progression through the minors, but I'm not sure many, if any, have been ruined by being selected Rule 5. They still get workouts under the best coaching in the system (maybe not the best for them)and pitch simulations with the best hitters in the game. I doubt they force anyone into pitching more IP than they should have- more likely it is almost always less real game innings, which can harm or stunt growth, but probably not in a long-lasting manner.
-
I still think Arauz would have become an all star had we not selected him Rule 5.
-
Yes, most prospects amount to squat, but many "suspects" become very useful players and even stars.
-
What were the chanced he'd be selected? 0.01%?
-
The trade for Yordan helped, too.
-
Good point. One could argue since nobody would likely claim Brasier and Ort off waivers, other GMs seemingly valued Song and Ward more than those two.
-
He only was ranked 9th on SP's out of the gate, and then he quickly fell to 11-13th, and later down to 17th and then out of the top 20 by mid 2017.
-
:rolleyes:
-
...and is anyone really "freaking out" over this?
-
I certainly do my share of high speculations. We have a local grocery chain that makes fresh squeezed OJ. I'm addicted.
-
I share your opinion that Ward and Song seemed to have more promise than Brasier, Ort and Hosmer. (We replaced Park with Chang and needed a middle IF'er on the 26 and 40.) I will say, there is a chance Brasier and Ort help us in 2023, where neither of these guys would. If Brasier and or Ort end up sucking and either of Ward or Song go on to do well, I'll be highly critical, too, but only time will tell. I do think we made a mistake, but it's all highly speculative, at this point.
-
It wasn't an "L," and I don't drink coffee. It was the "loser" comment you now ignore, which is what you do.
-
He just mentioned one source not to check. He did not imply that was the only source that counts. I'm glad you are not a judge.
-
Mr. Don't- make- it- personal shows his hypocrisy.
-
Moncada wasn't 29, but he made more on day one.
-
He may very likely end up being a dud, but he wasn't ranked 4th by SP's for no reason. (TWard reached 8th.)
-
Imagine, if they counted Yoshida!
-
That implies not states.
-
Not a bad list. I can't blame Yankee fans for liking their present standing in the here and now as well as the near and extended future, although some of these contracts will become over-bearing and you guys have a lot of aging players in very key roles in 2023. People talk about the Sox adding older guys like Jansen, Kluber and Turner, but the Yanks have more than their fair share, too, especially in the 32-34 range. Key roles held by older players: Sox DH Turner 38 SP2 Kluber 36 RP2 Martin 36 RP6 Bleier 35 CL Jansen 35 RP7 Brasier 35 CF Duvall 34 SP6 Paxton SP1 Sale 33 Yanks 3B Donaldson 37 UT LeMahieu 34 1B Rizzo 33 DH Stanton 33 LF Hicks 33 RP4 Kahnle 33 SP1 Cole 32 Red= key roles
-
Me, too. Even a guy like Paxton seems like a better bet, this year than the past two. I know Whitlock still has a lot to prove as a wire-to-wire SP'er, but if health or youth can be on our side, we should be able to yank him early or give him an off day, here and there, to help keep him fresh, all year. Having a stronger pen will help Cora decide on a quick hook a little more often, this year than last, although he was often accused of being too quick, last year with an awful pen. I'm not sure if the warming spring is fueling my optimism, but I'm feeling better and better about our chances as the days go by, despite no new additions or changes in players' outlooks.
