I’m not close to anointing him at anything. I’ve said his totality of moves grades to about a B- to C. Considering the budgets he has been handed and all the holes needed to be filled, he hasn’t done as badly as many seem to think he did, before last winter.
People remember trading away Renfroe but not the brilliant Renfroe signing for $3M.
They remember the s***** Beni trade but forget to look closely at what Beni production post trade and give time for the returns to be graded- like Winckowski.
They forget moves like getting Pivetta for 2 washed up RP’ers, finding decent but cheap players like Arroyo, Schreiber, Refsnyder, Whitlock, Bernardino and many more. Sure, he swung and missed on a lot of other low cost additions, but you get what you pay for and he did okay on this.
The Story signing looks worse with every day he misses. The Barnes extension was awful. The Richards and Kluber signings hurt badly, but he also signed Wacha, Hill, Strahm and a few others that more than earned their pay checks.
It’s too early to grade out Bloom. For all we know, Yoshida could crash and Burn. The Devers extension could explode before it even kicks in.
To me, based on speculation and conjecture, along with some results already in the books, I’d give Bloom this…
B+ or A- on farm building in 3.5 yrs, counting one list year of prospect development.
B for getting the budget under control, despite the fears that Story might be deadwood.
C+ on roster additions and subtractions beyond the draft and IFAs.