I hear you Doji. and i have debated this many times before. without a doubt most Sox fans definitely agree with you.
my deciding factor between the 2 is this:
Game 7, bottom of the 9th, bases loaded, 2 outs, down by 3. who do you think gives you the better chance to enjoy a parade?
Ted can have all his individual accomplishments. he was a great hitter. maybe the greatest hitter that ever walked this earth. but IMO David Ortiz is the greatest Red Sox player to have ever walked this earth. no individual stats that the splinter can present will change my mind. now if that seat was painted red because that is where the World Series winning HR landed i might reconsider......