Fine, I like Mookie too.
However, I have two responses to keeping him. First is that Mookie doesn't pitch, so the Sox pitching staff would have continued to disintegrate to mediocrity. Second is the example of the LA Angels, who have kept a truly great player in Mike Trout and gone nowhere in the postseason. Indeed, from 2018 to 2023, the had both Trout and Ohtani and went nowhere.
I am not arguing that JH has made the right decisions with respect to CBO's and/or level of spending. But I am saying I understand his frustration with all those big contracts that resulted in so-so performance.
As I have already said too many times, that frustration continues today with paying Sale $17M to star for the Braves, Turner $6.7M to play elsewhere, Story $22.5M to remain on the IL until 2025, ditto Giolito $18M, ditto Whitlock $3.2M, and $18.6M to Yoshida who is currently on the IL and whose hitting last year and this has not been commensurate with that salary.