In 2019 the Sox had the highest payroll in MLB and didn't make the playoffs with an 84-78 record. The year before, with basically the same players, they had the best season in Sox history, which was the 4th WS win in the John Henry era (2002-2024 and counting) after the 86 year WS drought.
So I think it's fair to say that JH understood the value of paying for talent. But 2019 was the perfect example of how expensive talent, especially pitching, doesn't necessarily deliver.
That's being repeated again this year. Top payroll, $307M, belongs to the Mets, who are 22-30. 3d is the Astros, $249M, who are 24-29, and 5th are the Rangers, $233M, who are 25-29. The Sox @ $182 will be 27-27 when this game is over.
Meanwhile, worth noting are the Orioles, 26th biggest payroll, $100M, who will be 34-18 after this game, the Guardians 25th biggest payroll, $101M, with a 36-17 record, the Brewers 22d payroll, $107M, with a 30-22 record, and the Royals 20th payroll, $116M, with a 34-20 record.
Back to Mookie, whose Dodgers payroll is 7th, $229M. They are currently 33-22, , which would put them behind the Orioles and their 26th payroll, $100M, and also behind the Royals, 34-20, and their 20th payroll, $116M.