But a SS has many more chances to make a difference in a game than a right fielder. And Smith's career average is .273, he was never an offensive liability the way JBJ is with a career average of 229.
I agree JBJ gets a great jump, so we may never really know the answer to a question that has to be asked: Just how many balls does JBJ get to in a week that the average ML outfielder (most are pretty damned good) do not? Is he really making more plays to offset all the additional empty at bats? We saw Duran got 17 hits in only 9 games, he isn't striking out and even many of his outs were hit well. In those 9 games (well it was actually 7 as he didn't play in 2 of them) JBJ got 3 hits, I didn't even bother to look up how many strikeouts but we know it's high.
Did Duran really not get to enough balls that JBJ would have tracked down in those games to offset all those additional hits? Not in my book.