I like Maddon - there is no super genius about managing per se. But if I were to hire a manager, I'd want somebody who is competent, smart - and can execute my priorities for the organization, and be flexible. Scioscia and Showalter would be problematic in that respect - Scioscia in particular - if an owner is going to let managers veto player personnel priorities, that would be very hard to deal with. This is not football or basketball where the org is small enough for that to be possible.
My choice would clearly be Francona - nice guy, media savvy - able to manage coaches and turn analytic results and information into action. And he understands player personnel priorities.