Strongly disagree.
Beni vs RHP 283/361/459 821 +108
Renfroe vs RHP 216/268/449 717 +85
Renfroe is terrible vs. RHP. His SLG is close to Beni's, but Beni's OBP is 93 points higher! That's not a big difference to you? (Correct me if I'm wrong, but you've always said you thought OPS inflates the value of SLG over OBP too much. I happen to agree with that.)
And we face RHP about 2/3 of the time, of course.