I am that poster, of course. Let me try to clarify my position once and for all.
Any suggestions I have made or will make that the Red Sox should have retained Bogaerts are based on the premise that they could have signed him for 6-7 years for 160-180 million, and not signed Story instead. No need for moon to point out again that we don't know if Bogaerts would have signed for that. I stipulate that he's right.
The contract Bogaerts got from the Padres was insane and I've never said I wanted the Red Sox to do that contract.
Yes, I do quote fWAR because it's an objective source of total player value.
As for Old School Numbers, Bogaerts's 2023 OPS of .767 does seem to be better than Story's 2023 OPS of .521. (Had to get a little snark in here.)