If you go back to when it happened, everyone seemed to agree it was the only thing that could be done at the time.
Same thing happened to Beltran of course, and he wasn't even under threat of discipline.
As for now, the media speculation, including Shaughnessy, seems to be that the Red Sox are very open to having to having him back. We're hearing how ownership loves him and the players all love him. Not a single negative thing other than the one-year suspension. All signs seem to be favorable.