Results speak for themselves.
The circumstance is age. Knuckler or no knuckler, 45 years of age is old, and the deterioration of his body and skills is pronounced. This is undeniable.
Also, the reliever point is not a position i presented. I just pointed out his numbers as a starter. Don't see where you got that from.
But his age, durability and effectiveness have. You're ignoring the biggest problem: His age. The decline is obvious. He has declined every season since three years ago. It is a trend.
Let's not try to pretend like 45 is the new 35. There's a reason why not a lot of people play deep into their 40's, and even though he's a knuckleballer, it is clear that he basically has nothing left.
The "fans" deserve to see me break the record" comment. I thought it harmless, but people have run with that s*** and overreacted, just like they have with Ortiz, the beer and chicken crew, and Crawford.