I'll tell you why: What role players had unsustainable all-star seasons? That is retarded. If you say Nava, you know that's a load of s*** What aging veterans "returned to their prime"? If you're talking about Ortiz, the production hadn't tailed off at all and he missed a chunk of time at the beginning of the season. Where's the unheralded durability? Oh, and what about half the f***ing roster being injured at one time or the other? The "lucky" season had a lot more to do with depth than with luck. The loss of Ellsbury will hurt, but Salty was still terrible defensively and Drew ain't gone yet. Even if he is, well, there's a pretty good chance XB outproduces him next year anyway.
I know it really pisses you off, but it's clear that the Red Sox are still the better team, and luck ain't why. Obviously, the assertion SoxSport is making that "they may have a better team" is dumb beyond words, but your doomsday device crap is just as dumb. The truth lies somewhere in the middle.