The problem wasn't the plan, it was the execution. I also find the idea that they couldn't remain competitive with a strong offense to be intelectually dishonest, as the 2005 Red Sox will attest to. That said, while the pitching has sucked, no one could have predicted both starting catchers getting injured (which has invariably hurt the pitching staff), the fall of Napoli, as well as general offensive underperformance. They should have (and a lot of people harped on this) gotten at least one more pitcher, and improved their pitching depth knowing the gambles they were taking pitching-wise.