1.- just because they come from the same team, makes them equal? I don't think so Pal. Correct me if I'm wrong but I have noticed that your arguments often rest on that you wouldn't bring a pitcher from other division to the AL East, but you let walk your ace in the pen and let somebody else unproved substitue him from other division? I don't get it.
2.- I said, if the deal is straight up, I'd do it, otherwise I would not.
3.- jacko already posted my concerns about Youk. IMO, Today, not career but today, Santana>Youk. Hell, I see a lot of red flags on Youk, seems like his career is not getting better but the opposite, but that's me.