I think it was the first poll which I participated when I said that TW101, A700, SCM33, etc were the most knowledgable posters at the time. He used to participate actively. Somehow he is not posting as he used to, probably because his activities doesn't allow him, IDK. Also, he has an amount of posts which back up his interventions. IMO He has brought a lot to the table. In my case time to time I do not post that often as well because my personal life doesn't give me a chance, and when I want to post something when I have a chance, some have called me troll or whatever when I do not say good things about the team. I do not care, really, they are the same people.
In most of the cases I do not think it is an overreaction thing. Some posters saw this coming in the offseason, specially regarding pitching. Some said that it was going to be "good enough" and some like me said that this pitching staff could turn out into the worst rotation in the last 10 Y which is happening. Sure, it is still early, but honestly I do not see how this could turn around. If you had a guy like Lester who is struggling I could understand a real come back, because the stuff is there, but this staff? I see very little chances. Again, that is my opinion.